Do you prefer to create brand new things, or to refine a craft?
Having just told you not to box yourself in, I thought I’d explore a preference that divides up a lot of creative people (which includes pretty much anyone, but should be relevant to the people in my audience who are building software products ).
Artisans love to refine things, to build the perfect example of their craft. Think of really well put together pieces of furniture, excellently shaped vases or refined and complex mechanical watches. They practice, they get better. The artisan will create many things, and probably never acknowledge a single completed item as perfect.
Inventors go all out. They may have a stunning success or a miserable failure, but they’ll go for it anyway. They probably only enjoy getting to the end of a project and creating the first thing. They don’t go back around to improve, they pickup a new idea and go again.
It’s a preference, so sometimes you’ll flick between the two approaches. If you’re in artisan mode and work with an inventor, then sparks can fly (and vice versa!). A great collaboration can come into being if you recognise this early. Let the inventor rip up the rule book, create a wild prototype and then the artisan can refine towards perfection.
You might think that an artisan is just siphoning energy from their flywheel of change while the inventor is draining it rapidly. That might be true in some situations, but the effort and focus required by a master artisan to strive for perfection is just as significant and draining.
So what’s your preference?